Rodgers telah lima kali tersisih di fase knock out Liga Europa dengan tiga tim berbeda, yakni Liverpool (2012-2013, 2014-2015), Celtic (2017-2018, 2018-2019), dan Leicester City (2020-2021).
Berikut hasil lengkap leg kedua babak 32 besar Liga Europa dilansir BolaSport.com dari laman resmi UEFA:
- Tottenham Hotspur 4-0 (Agg: 8-1) Wolfsberger AC (Dele Alli 11', Carlos Vinicius 50', 83', Gareth Bale 73')
- AFC Ajax 2-1 (Agg: 4-2) Lille (Davy Klaassen 15', David Neres 88'; Yusuf Yazici 78'-pen)
- Shakhtar Donetsk 1-0 (Agg: 3-0) Maccabi Tel Aviv (Junior Moraes 67'-pen)
- Napoli 2-1 (Agg: 2-3) Granada (Piotr Zielinski 3', Fabian Ruiz 59'; Angel Montoro 25')
- Hoffenheim 0-2 (Agg: 3-4) Molde (Ulland Andersen 20')
- Villarreal 2-1 (Agg: 4-1) Salzburg FC (Gerard Moreno 40',89'-pen; Mergim Berisha 17')
- Rangers 5-2 (Agg: 8-5) Royal Antwerp (Alfredo Morelos 9', Nathan Patterson 46', Ryan Kent 55', Borna Barisic 79'-pen, Cedric Itten 90+2'-pen; Lior Refaelov 32', Didier Lamkel Ze 57')
- Arsenal 3-2 (Agg: 4-3) Benfica (Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang 21',87', Kieran Tierney 67'; Diogo Goncalves 43', Rafa Silva 61')
- PSV Eindhoven 2-1 (Agg: 4-5) Olympiacos (Eran Zahavi 23', 44'; Ahmed Hassan 88')
- Bayern Leverkusen 0-2 (Agg: 3-6) Young Boys (Jordan Sibeatcheu 48', Christian Fassnacht 86')
- Dinamo Zagreb 1-0 (Agg: 4-2) Krasnodar (Mislav Orsic 31')
- AS Roma 3-1 (Agg: 5-1) SC Braga (Edin Dzeko 24', Carles Perez 75', Borja Mayoral 90+1'; Bryan Cristante 88'-bd)
- Leicester City 0-2 (Agg: 0-2) Slavia Praha (Lukas Provod 49', Abdallah Sima 79')
- AC Milan 1-1 (Agg: 3-3) Crvena Zvezda (Franck Kessie 9'-pen; Ben Nabouhane 24')
- Manchester United 0-0 (Agg: 4-0) Real Sociedad
- Club Brugge 0-0 (Agg: 1-2) Dynamo Kyiv (Vitaliy Buyalskiy 83')